Players who played for the New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays
135 MLB players have played for both the New York Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays, regular season or playoffs, listed by career games. Teams that moved count for the team they became: the Brooklyn Dodgers count for Los Angeles, the New York Giants for San Francisco, the Montreal Expos for Washington and the Philadelphia and Kansas City Athletics for today's Athletics.
- Rickey Henderson3,081 GP
- Dave Winfield2,973 GP
- John Olerud2,234 GP
- Ruben Sierra2,186 GP
- Tony Fernandez2,158 GP
- Curtis Granderson2,057 GP
- Edwin Encarnacion1,960 GP
- Jose Canseco1,887 GP
- Melky Cabrera1,887 GP
- Vernon Wells1,731 GP
- Otis Nixon1,709 GP
- Dave Collins1,701 GP
- Russell Martin1,693 GP
- John Mayberry1,620 GP
- Lyle Overbay1,587 GP
- Raul Mondesi1,525 GP
- Juan Beniquez1,500 GP
- Miguel Cairo1,490 GP
- Lee Mazzilli1,475 GP
- Randal Grichuk1,474 GP
- Cecil Fielder1,470 GP
- Mike Stanley1,467 GP
- Jesse Barfield1,428 GP
- Kelly Johnson1,399 GP
- Eric Hinske1,387 GP
- Josh Donaldson1,384 GP
- Cliff Johnson1,369 GP
- Kendrys Morales1,363 GP
- Rick Cerone1,329 GP
- Troy Tulowitzki1,291 GP
- Mariano Duncan1,279 GP
- Glenallen Hill1,162 GP
- David Dellucci1,099 GP
- Juan Rivera1,058 GP
- LaTroy Hawkins1,042 GP
- Damaso Garcia1,032 GP
- Dioner Navarro1,009 GP
- Isiah Kiner-Falefa979 GP
- David Weathers967 GP
- Jose Molina947 GP
- Mark Whiten940 GP
- Adeiny Hechavarria922 GP
- Brandon Drury867 GP
- Phil Niekro866 GP
- Gio Urshela851 GP
- Luis Sojo848 GP
- Paul Quantrill841 GP
- Tyler Clippard807 GP
- Steve Pearce766 GP
- Armando Benitez762 GP
- Octavio Dotel758 GP
- Dave Righetti718 GP
- Roger Clemens709 GP
- Pat Kelly681 GP
- Yangervis Solarte670 GP
- David Wells660 GP
- Otto Velez637 GP
- Jim Mason633 GP
- John Candelaria603 GP
- Mike Morgan597 GP
- Rob Refsnyder594 GP
- Dewayne Wise576 GP
- Graeme Lloyd568 GP
- Ben Francisco563 GP
- Doyle Alexander562 GP
- Dave Revering557 GP
- Todd Greene536 GP
- Tony Solaita525 GP
- Dale Murray518 GP
- Jon Berti514 GP
- Felix Heredia511 GP
- Domingo Ramos507 GP
- Bobby Brown502 GP
- Jimmy Key471 GP
- Jayson Nix466 GP
- Josh Phelps465 GP
- Xavier Hernandez464 GP
- David Cone451 GP
- Greg Cadaret451 GP
- Tim Mayza442 GP
- A. J. Burnett436 GP
- Sal Fasano427 GP
- Miguel Castro425 GP
- Al Leiter419 GP
- Alberto Castillo418 GP
- Nick Green418 GP
- Homer Bush409 GP
- Phil Coke407 GP
- Chad Green382 GP
- Tom Underwood380 GP
- Esteban Loaiza379 GP
- David Phelps368 GP
- Juan Acevedo367 GP
- J. A. Happ360 GP
- Ted Lilly357 GP
- Chad Gaudin346 GP
- Erik Kratz335 GP
- Jacob Barnes334 GP
- Billy McKinney327 GP
- Bobby Estalella310 GP
- Mark Leiter306 GP
- Paul Mirabella298 GP
- Joe Mantiply281 GP
- Cory Lidle277 GP
- Marcus Stroman277 GP
- Tanyon Sturtze272 GP
- Tom Buskey258 GP
- Jeff Francis256 GP
- Ryan Yarbrough253 GP
- Anthony Banda248 GP
- Kevin Cash246 GP
- Jameson Taillon242 GP
- David Carpenter223 GP
- Jaime Garcia222 GP
- Esmil Rogers221 GP
- Robert Perez221 GP
- Carlos Almanzar210 GP
- Jonathan Davis205 GP
- Mickey Klutts199 GP
- Bob Macdonald197 GP
- Sergio Santos194 GP
- Chien-Ming Wang174 GP
- Aaron Small172 GP
- Ryan Dull171 GP
- Aaron Laffey156 GP
- Josh Towers139 GP
- Kevin Smith116 GP
- Jimmy Cordero114 GP
- Chris Latham110 GP
- A. J. Cole109 GP
- Ali Sanchez99 GP
- Breyvic Valera93 GP
- Ryota Igarashi83 GP
- Don Cooper44 GP
- Ted Wilborn30 GP
Think you know them all?
The New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays could share a square on today's grid. Name a player who fits both headings on an Ultimate Tic-Tac-Toe board.
More team pairs
- New York Yankees and Oakland Athletics
- Baltimore Orioles and New York Yankees
- Cleveland Guardians and New York Yankees
- Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees
- Chicago White Sox and New York Yankees
- Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Yankees
- New York Mets and Toronto Blue Jays
- Oakland Athletics and Toronto Blue Jays
- Seattle Mariners and Toronto Blue Jays
- Texas Rangers and Toronto Blue Jays
- Chicago Cubs and Toronto Blue Jays
- Los Angeles Angels and Toronto Blue Jays
Data: the SABR Lahman Baseball Database, covering everyone who played from 1901 on.